The Best Pizza in Marin: Where to Find the Most Mouthwatering Slices

Introduction

Looking for the best pizza in Marin? Whether you're a local or just passing through the beautiful county north of the Golden Gate Bridge, you're in luck. Marin County offers a surprisingly diverse and delicious pizza scene—from traditional Neapolitan-style pies to creative California-inspired slices.

In this guide, we’ll explore the top spots for pizza lovers, what makes them stand out, and why they deserve a visit.

What Makes Marin County a Secret Treasure for Pizza Lovers

Marin may be better known for redwoods, hiking trails, and scenic coastline, but it's also home to a vibrant culinary culture. The pizza here benefits from the region’s commitment to farm-to-table ingredients, artisan cooking methods, and an emphasis on quality over quantity.

1. Pizzalina – San Anselmo’s Cozy Pizza Haven

Address: 914 Sir Francis Drake Blvd, San Anselmo, CA

Pizzalina tops many lists for the best pizza in Marin, and for good reason. This neighborhood spot offers wood-fired, Neapolitan-inspired pizzas using organic and locally sourced ingredients. Their crust—crispy outside, soft and chewy inside—is a masterpiece.

What to try:

Margherita D.O.P.
Sausage & Kale with Calabrian chili oil
Roasted Brussels Sprouts appetizer

2. Tony Tutto Pizza – A Quirky Favorite in Mill Valley

Address: 246 E Blithedale Ave, Mill Valley, CA

Tony Tutto Pizza is as unique as its name. With a hyper-local, vegetarian-leaning menu and an artsy vibe, Tony’s serves up bold, creative flavor combinations. Every pizza is hand-stretched and made to order.

Why it stands out:

Unique toppings like truffle oil, figs, or heirloom tomatoes
Ultra-thin, crispy crust
Organic and non-GMO ingredients

Fan favorite: The "Local Wild Mushroom" pizza

3. Napoli – An Old-School Staple in Vallejo with a Loyal Marin Following

Address: 124 Tennessee St, Vallejo, CA
(Easy access for Marin residents via the Richmond Bridge)

Though technically just outside Marin, Napoli Pizzeria has a cult following among locals for its classic East Coast-style pies. This no-frills joint has been serving consistently great pizza since the 1950s.

Why it’s worth the drive:

Generous portions
Homemade dough and sauce
Classic pepperoni and sausage combo that never disappoints

4. Mulberry Street Pizzeria – New York Taste in San Rafael

Address: 101 Smith Ranch Rd, San Rafael, CA

The Mulberries Pizza serves a thin crust pizza in a NYC manner. Known for large, foldable slices and a laid-back atmosphere, it’s perfect for lunch breaks or a casual dinner.

Top choices:

White Pizza with ricotta and garlic
BBQ Chicken
Classic Cheese Slice (for purists)

5. Flour Craft Pizza (Coming Soon!) – Gluten-Free Pizza in Marin

Flour Craft Bakery has been a pioneer in gluten-free pastries in Marin, and now it’s expanding into pizza. Set to open in late 2025, Flour Craft Pizza promises artisanal, 100% gluten-free pies with seasonal toppings and wood-fired flair.

Why you should keep an eye out:

Dedicated gluten-free kitchen
Chef-driven, seasonal menus
Locally loved for their pastries and breads

Final Thoughts: Where Will You Find the Best Pizza in Marin?

The best pizza in Marin ultimately depends on your taste—whether you’re a fan of thin-crust New York style, rich Neapolitan pies, or experimental, veggie-forward creations. What they all have in common is a love for quality, craftsmanship, and community.

So next time you’re in Marin, skip the chain restaurants and check out one of these local gems. Your taste buds will thank you.